First page of the Management Review Control Documentation TemplateWord document preview

SOX and ICFR

Management Review Control Documentation Template

Management review control template in Word: control facts, risk, review steps, precision thresholds, report validation, evidence and a worked flux review.

Word document · 41 KB Built on free official texts

3 free downloads per account. Just your email and a 6-digit code.

Need more than 3? Every template for $249, once. Lifetime access, including the templates we add later. See pricing

About this template

A management review control is a review by a manager of results, analyses or reconciliations that is meant to catch a misstatement. Auditors look hard at these controls because a review can look the same whether it was precise or a glance. This document records one review control in enough detail that a tester can see what is reviewed, at what threshold, using which reports and with what evidence.

The template has twelve sections, from control identification and the risk addressed to evidence and testing attributes. It applies the SEC's 2007 interpretive guidance for management, Release 33-8810, on precision and on controls that rely on system information. It also reflects the auditor's duty in PCAOB AS 1105 to test the accuracy and completeness of company information. A worked example shows a monthly subscription revenue review at an invented company.

Who it is for

The control owner or SOX lead whose auditor said a management review control lacks documented precision and evidence, and who must rewrite it before the next test.

What is inside

  • 12 numbered sections, written for one review control
  • Control identification table with 11 fields
  • Precision table: 4 review lines with expectation, threshold and basis
  • Information used table for 4 reports with how completeness and accuracy are established
  • Worked example: a monthly subscription revenue review with 5 review lines, 4 over threshold
  • Testing attributes table with 6 attributes a tester inspects
  • Checklist of 6 decisions to make before use

How to use it

Copy the control facts from your control matrix into section 3, then set each threshold below the amount that could be material.

Files

  • DOCXmanagement-review-control-documentation-template.docx41 KB

Opens in Microsoft Word or Excel, Google Docs or Sheets, and LibreOffice. Built on free, official texts that anyone can read: laws, regulations, standards and guidance published by public bodies. A template to adapt, not legal, tax or accounting advice.

Questions about this template

What is precision in a management review control?

Precision is how small a misstatement the review would find. The SEC's 2007 guidance says a control that addresses a financial reporting risk must operate at a level of precision that would prevent or detect a misstatement that could be material. In practice that means written thresholds, an expectation to compare against and a rule for what is investigated.

What evidence shows a management review was performed?

Evidence shows what was reviewed, which items exceeded the threshold, what explanation was obtained, how it was corroborated and what follow-up was done. A signature alone shows only that someone looked. Annotated analyses, emails asking questions and the resolution of each item are stronger.

Why do reports used in a review need to be validated?

A review is only as reliable as the data it uses. PCAOB AS 1105 tells auditors to test the accuracy and completeness of information produced by the company, or the controls over it. Management therefore documents how each report used in the review is known to be complete and accurate.